Charles Martinet, the longtime voice of Mario, is leaving the iconic role, and people are not happy about it – even though it’s understandable that at almost 70 years old, he may be seeking a less strenuous job. Martinet’s retirement is seen by many as a chance for him to go out on a high note while still being involved in the franchise, but fans are already expressing their dismay and concern about the incoming new voice.
Martinet’s fantastic portrayal of Mario is regarded by many as the definitive voice, but it seems that Nintendo has decided to go in a different direction. Comparisons are already being made to other iconic voice actors like Mark Hamill and James Earl Jones, who have experienced changes in their voices over time, and there’s no real consensus on whether it matters or not.
Some users express their preference for Hamill’s portrayal of the Joker in the ‘90s over the newer one, while others highlight the physical demands of voice acting and how it can affect an actor’s voice over time. Martinet’s interactions with fans at conventions are applauded, and overall, the sentiment is one of wishing him well and welcoming the new Voice Actor with open arms.
“What are you talking about?” I hear you say. “He’s the best!”
Yes, he is. But everybody has to retire at some point. We wish him well.
“Mario is a very physical character, so I’m sure the new guy will make it his own. Just be welcoming and patient,” one user responds. “Don’t be mean,” another implores. “Be welcoming,” a third echoes.
There’s some skepticism regarding Martinet’s interactions with fans as well, with a couple of users suggesting that he may not genuinely consider everyone his number one fan. It’s certainly possible – I’ve interviewed voice actors before, and it’s always clear that they have a different relationship with their fans than the one we have with them. They’re professionals, whereas we’re essentially fangirls and fanboys.
The thread also discusses Martinet’s work outside of the Mario games, with his roles in Skyrim, Dragon Ball Super, and more highlighted. Some users also touch on the financial aspect of Martinet’s career, with suggestions that he may have earned substantial income from his roles.
“Just because he’s been doing it for decades doesn’t mean he’s been making tons of money,” one user replies. “It’s very easy to assume that because you’ve never done it,” another responds.
“I don’t understand why people think voice acting is braindead and easy,” one user says.
