Mass Effect 2 is the best game in the series, according to Mass Effect Reddit

The best Mass Effect memories are forged in Mass Effect 2.

That’s the consensus among Mass Effect Redditors as they share their opinions on the best PC games based in the science-fiction series. The RPG game is hailed as the best in the series, with genuine friendships formed in-game cited as the reason why the Mass Effect trilogy stands out as a favorite franchise.

“Mass Effect 2 was a masterpiece in gameplay and storytelling,” one user writes. “The distinct classes, the improvements to the combat, the interactions, the story, the planet scanner, the loyalty missions, the humor, the build-up to the suicide mission, the impact it had on the series when we lost people, the sense of dread it created, the sense of accomplishment, EDI, the quarians and their history, the geth and their history, the Reapers, TIM, the list goes on.”

Another user agrees, saying, “I honestly think it’s the best in the series. It set the bar for the series in terms of gameplay and storytelling.”

However, it’s not all praise. “I know I’m going to get some hate for this,” another user replies, “but I honestly think Mass Effect 3 was a garbage game overall. I’m not just talking about the ending. I don’t think the gameplay was great, the story felt rushed, and it was too streamlined.”

“Definitely don’t agree with the first part,” another user replies. “I do recognize that the ending taints the view of the game, but it does have its strengths. The gameplay is still great and it’s one of my favorite series, but I still find myself going back to 2 more.”

Despite the criticism of the ending and its impact on Mass Effect 3’s reputation, it’s still regarded highly by many users, alongside the Citadel DLC. Many also argue that dismissing the entire game because of one ending is unfair, while others believe people are just mad that the series has ended and can’t think of a better alternative ending.

In any case, the ending is seen as disappointing but doesn’t overshadow the overall journey, with the quality of the ending compared to the high standards set by the rest of the series.

Mass Effect 2 is also regarded highly for its character progression and gameplay, while Mass Effect 3 is favored for its gameplay, even if the story feels rushed and lacking. Others argue that the first Mass Effect is still worth playing, despite its outdated gameplay.

Here are some of the best Mass Effect memories shared by players, courtesy of Mass Effect Subreddit:

• “The first time we got to the Citadel in ME1 and realized just how big the universe was. Exploring the Prothean ruins in ME2 and finding all the hidden stuff. The emotional impact of the elevator scene with Mordin in ME3.”
• “ME2 was the first game in the series I played and will always be my favorite. The fact that the classes were distinct, the gameplay improvements, the interactions, and the fact that it was the first game where I felt like my decisions mattered, and the friendships I made with all my crew members.”
• “The Citadel DLC. It was an apology for the botched ending.”
• “The combat and multiplayer of ME3, the jump jets in MEA, and the Citadel DLC.”
• “The friendships I made in ME2 multiplayer, and the Citadel DLC.”
• “I absolutely loved exploring the Citadel in ME1 and learning about the different races. I also loved the loyalty missions in ME2.”
• “The original ending of Mass Effect 3.”
• “The first time seeing the Citadel in ME1 and realizing just how big the universe was.”
• “The Citadel in ME1 and Mordin dying in ME3.”
• “The emotional impact of the ending.”
• “The emotional impact of the ending.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “Exploring the Prothean ruins in ME2 and finding all the hidden stuff.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “Remembering how much I loved spending time on the Citadel in ME1 and learning about the different races.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “Exploring the Prothean ruins in ME2 and finding all the hidden stuff.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “The Citadel in ME1, the loyalty missions in ME2, and the whole journey in ME3.”
• “Getting to know all the characters in ME2 and the Citadel DLC.”